by claiming that other animals do not have souls.
Nonetheless, this pig has
soul.
And perhaps these ones would, too.
I warn you, though. Do not be misled by the shots of free cattle, pigs, and chickens near the end of the video. The proposition would not ensure this. Animals could and would still be produced using battery and intensive methods, but they would be allowed the minimal space necessary to turn around and extend their limbs. Imagine if you were, from infancy, kept in a cage in which you could not lift your arms or extend your legs. This is the reality of these beings. Behaviors, such as wing flapping and dust bathing, are hardwired in chickens, and similar behaviors are in other animals. Psychosis routinely disturbs these animals; chickens beaks are seared off to avoid chicken death (lost profits), and pigs must have their tails removed because after such confinement their fellow pigs behind them will out of boredom and confusion painfully gnaw off the tail in front of them, leaving festering, infected wounds.
Furthermore, the law ONLY COVERS pregnant pigs, veal calves, and egg-laying hens. All other pigs will be produced under the
same conditions.
Additionally, the law does not apply to procedures deemed "scientific or agricultural research," nor of course during transportation, nor for entertainment uses ("rodeo exhibitions, state or county fair exhibitions, 4-H programs, and similar exhibitions"), nor for the seven days prior to the "expected" day of birth of a mother sow.
Breaking this law is a misdemeanor with a fine not to exceed $1,000 and county jailing not to exceed 180 days.
This would not do nearly enough to ensure that animals would live lives that, though short, were flourishing and fulfilled. This does not ensure that their basic interests are seen to. This is a minimal measure that would be cynical were the situation not, at present, so dire.
It is also worth noting that by outlawing battery practices, this can ultimately take a small step towards increasing competition amongst farmers and upset our class system as smaller producers enter the market. But most likely this will not have great effects on the animal agriculture market.
But it will have a great effect on the lives of millions of animals. Animals that will still be miserable and will still require our advocacy, but will be one step closer to a relative liberation.
Vote YES on Proposition 2. And continue to support animals. Make California a leader in extending our sphere of moral consideration to species that, though they cannot speak human languages, can feel as much as you or I.